Article by Gordon
Chalmers
Article Published 13 September
2007
Fat is the major fuel needed by racing pigeons during the racing
season, and indeed, by any species of wild bird that flies extended
distances, as in Spring and Fall migrations. It has been noted that
the capability of birds for storing triglycerides as an energy reserve,
exceeds that of other classes of vertebrates (Blem, 1976). The fatty
acids of these triglycerides are predominantly of the 16 and 18-carbon
variety, and generally, are more unsaturated than those of mammals.
The facts about fat as the key fuel for racing were established
many years ago, and considerable work on this subject was undertaken
in Canada by Dr. John George, his colleagues and graduate students
at the University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario. More recently, it
seems that some very exciting work by Professor Rothe, who used
pigeons in wind tunnels at Saarbrucken, Germany, reaffirmed the
fact that, truly, fat is the main fuel involved in the production
of energy for racing. Logically then, providing diets containing
increased amounts of fat, could be very helpful in providing the
highly important fuel reserves needed for racing, right? Well,
possibly...... Perusal of available literature on the metabolism
of protein, carbohydrate and fat in birds in general revealed
some interesting information that could be very useful in preparing
pigeons for racing. Here are some of the facts taken from pertinent
scientific literature on birds.
Firstly, in birds, it is known that less than 4% of depot fat,
that is, fat found in the body cavity, under the skin, etc., is
actually produced in these locations. Where then, is the great
majority of fat actually synthesized? Well, not surprisingly,
in pigeons the liver is the major organ in which the vast amount
of fat is produced. In fact, in birds, about 47% of the fat produced
for use in the body is produced in the liver, 44% in the carcass,
7% in the skin, and 2% in the intestines. It is known that when
the relative weights of tissues are taken into account, the liver
of birds is 20 times as active per unit of weight in the production
of fat as is the carcass. However, it is interesting to note as
well that bone marrowis another important site for fat production
in birds, and that bone marrow itself has about two thirds of
the fat-producing activity of liver. After it is produced in the
liver, fat is transported in the bloodstream to the body depots
for storage, and very importantly, to working muscles where it
serves as a ready fuel supply for sustained flight.
Fine so far, but there are a couple of interesting points to
consider.... Logic would say that the addition of extra fat to
the diet of racing pigeons would help the liver with production,
and would just add to the amount of fat produced normally by the
liver, and subsequently exported to storage sites.
In fact, one study several years ago showed that the addition
of the vegetable oil, corn oil (a vegetable oil is simply a liquid
fat) in the amount of 5% to the diet of racing pigeons, improved
performances, especially from beyond 200 miles, whereas birds
that were not supplemented with corn oil had poorer performances
overall. The addition of extra fat to the diet should assist the
body in building fat reserves. My reading around the subject of
the energy requirements of birds turned up some very interesting,
surprising, and potentially useful information that could be of
value in the preparation of pigeons for racing. The following
facts need to be pondered, mulled over, and if judged to have
some merit, acted upon accordingly:
Point #1 -- high levels of fat in the diet of birds will
DECREASE the amount of fat produced by the liver (Griminger, 1986).
Point #2 -- high levels of protein in the diet of birds
will DECREASE the amount of fat produced by the liver!!
Point #3 -- high levels of carbohydrate in the diet of
birds will INCREASE the amount of fat produced by the liver (Griminger,
1986).
In one study in chickens, it was found that the addition of 10%
corn oil to the diet of young chicks actually decreased fat production
in the liver by a startling 40%! However, it is important to note
that when amounts of carbohydrate in the diet are held at a constant
level, high levels of dietary fat don't interfere with fat production
by the liver! Another important point is that stored fat in the
body, including the flight muscles, is obtained not only from
production in the liver, but also from fat absorbed from the diet
through the wall of the intestines.
Now, let's try to translate some of this information so that
it has a bit more meaning for fanciers. Firstly, the great majority
of fat in the body of the racing pigeon is produced by the liver,
from which it is then transported in the bloodstream to depots
(also called storage areas), and to red fibers in the muscles,
for direct use as a source of energy during flight. Fat that is
present the diet is also absorbed through the intestines and is
transported to muscles and depot areas as well. As fat is needed
by working muscle, it is mobilized from nearby sources and from
these depots, and moved through the bloodstream to the muscles.
Preferential use of fat by flight muscles allows for a more efficient
liberation of energy during prolonged, strenuous flights such
as those of migrating birds, and of racing pigeons. There is some
difference of opinion among fanciers as to whether depot fat is
really utilized as a source of fuel. The information I have at
this point is that experiments on pigeons at the University of
Guelph showed that after a minimum of 30 minutes of exercise,
the amount of fat in depots decreased by almost 25%, and that,
correspondingly, the amount of fat in the breast muscles increased
by about the same amount.
This work also demonstrated that the amount of fat in the bloodstream
increased by about 18%, and in the liver, by about 30%. These
investigations indicate to me that fat is indeed mobilized from
depot areas, transported in the bloodstream, and taken up by the
liver and working muscle.
It has been established in other species such as the laboratory
rat that depot fat is not static, and that in this species, there
is a complete recycling of depot fat every 10 days. Therefore,
depot fat seems to be a dynamic system involved in the synthesis,
oxidation, storage and release of fats in some species. Despite
this general information, it is known that in pigeons, very little
synthesis of fat occurs in depot areas. However, in migratory
birds, it is known that peritoneal or "migratory" fat
is distinguished from subcutaneous fat or "winter" fat.
Migratory fat accumulates rapidly in large amounts just prior
to migration, and is exhausted at the end of migration (Odum and
Perkinson, 1951). It may well be that the fat we build each week
in racing pigeons is of the "migratory" type, because
of the rapid ccumulation of large amounts of "pre- racing"
fat in the few days before shipping. Since the amount of glycogen
-- a complex sugar which is really the storage form of glucose
-- in red fibers is relatively small compared with the amount
of fat present, it can't be considered to be a serious contender
as a major source of fuel for flying any distance, despite some
persisting views that it is.
Incidentally, in less than two hours after feeding glucose, either
as the sugar given in water, or after the conversion of starch
from grains into glucose in the intestines, there is rapid production
of glycogen by the liver of birds. Some glycogen is stored by
the liver and some is exported in the blood to muscles and other
tissues as a source of energy. Glucose is the major source of
fuel for the brain. As well, a study by Goodridge and Ball (1967)
revealed that significant carbon derived from intravenously injected
glucose-U- 14C was incorporated into fatty acids of liver within
three minutes in pigeons, and that the content of radioactive
fatty acids in liver reached a plateau in 15 minutes.
Significant appearance of labelled fatty acids in blood and fat
depots was seen first at 15 minutes, and their concentration rose
continuously throughout the two-hour experimental period. During
this trial, the authors calculated that the liver was converting
glucose to fatty acids at a rate 25 times faster than that of
the fat depots. not have the capacity for the conversion of glucose
to fatty acids, compared with that of liver. It also indicated
that the regulation of fat synthesis in the pigeon must occur
in the liver. If we try to assist the liver by adding more fat
to the diet, say by the use of grains containing high amounts
of fat -- grains such as peanuts that contain almost 50% fat (and
a high level of protein, -- about 30%, note) -- actually, we may
be causing a marked decrease in the amount of fat that the liver
is capable of producing for the energy requirements of flight!
A decrease of 40% production of fat by the liver in the face of
a high level of fat in the diet could be a pretty significant
decrease!
However -- it is possible that compensation for this decrease
may occur, by the presence of fat absorbed by the intestines from
the diet. When this dietary fat is mixed with bile in the intestines,
it is absorbed directly through the wall of the intestines as
a source of fuel. However, it seems that most of the fat in storage
depots and in red muscle is produced by the liver. Another important
point to re-iterate in this discussion of fat is that fat synthesis
by the liver of birds is greatly inhibited when dietary levels
of carbohydrate in the ration are concurrently low. By contrast,
there appears to be little reduction in the production of fat
by the liver when dietary levels of carbohydrate are maintained
at a relatively high level. It is quite possible, and indeed,
very likely, given these facts, that adding a high amount of fat
through the addition of a significant percentage of peanuts, for
example, could significantly reduce the amount of fat manufactured
by the liver. When we add peanuts to a significant level of the
ration, in effect we have removed a similar weight of one or more
of the other grains already in the diet. Regardless of the number
or amounts of grains added to the diet, it is obvious that the
total weight of all grains used in a particular mix, adds up to
100%.
The grains that are likely to be replaced by peanuts are the
carbohydrate-rich cereal grains, such as wheat, barley, rice,
oats and corn, and this may well be the nub of the issue. Remember
that diets high in carbohydrate result in a high production of
fat by the liver. Remember too that peanuts are very high in fat
content, but they are also very high in protein -- and also importantly,
low in carbohydrate. Diets high in fat and high in protein result
in decreased fat production by the liver! To offset the effects
of diets high in fat, one simple, key method is to maintain a
high level of carbohydrate in the diet when the fat-loaded grains
are added. Here is another very important point. As noted by Dr.
Pawloski (1991) in his very informative article in the R.P. Bulletin,
diets high in protein may also cause increased thirst in pigeons,
because of the high amounts of uric acid (from the metabolism
of the high per centage of protein in peanuts and other high-protein
grains) that have to be excreted through the kidneys.
This uric acid (also called urates) is concentrated in the white
tip seen when droppings are passed. This excretory process requires
water to flush the uric acid and its salts out of the kidneys.
Result: loss of water from the body which, in turn, results in
increased thirst to replace the water lost in the flushing process,
something that we want to avoid at almost all costs, especially
when birds are due to be sent racing.
So the use of diets high in protein, including the use of high
amounts of peanuts in the few days just before shipping, probably
causes unnecessary thirst on the road and should be avoided, according
to Dr. Pawloski. It certainly makes sense. If high-protein grains
are to be fed during the racing season for the repair and maintenance
of muscles and other tissues for example, it seems logical then
that they should be fed earlier rather than later in the week
-- say up to mid-week and no later. As well, protein is not really
an energy food, although it certainly can be used for this purpose,
but likely only when all other fat and carbohydrate sources of
energy have been exhausted. For these reasons, and because protein
tends to be the most expensive component of a diet, it should
be reduced in amount in the ration in the few days prior to shipping,
to allow for a build up of fat reserves from carbohydrates, and
to avoid problems of increased thirst.
What are some methods that we could use to deal with
all of these facts?
One simple, obvious, safe way to build necessary fat reserves
would be to revert to a traditional diet of mainly cereal grains,
including a high per centage of corn (say, 40% or more), and completely
avoid the high-fat grains when birds are racing. This would also
mean that the amount of legumes in the ration during the racing
season -- peas, beans, lentils, etc. -- should also be reduced
from the amounts used for breeding and rearing, because of their
high content of protein, and associated thirst, to say nothing
of the cost.
Another clue that we can use to advantage is this: eating a
meal, as opposed to nibbling in a hopper-feeding situation, increases
fat production in birds. So, it seems that those who feed pigeons
a meal once or twice a day during racing, may actually bring about
a greater production of fat to be used for fuel than those who
hopper feed. Would hopper feeding be best for short-distance racing,
and meal feeding best for long- distance racing?? Just an idea.....
3. Another practical approach during racing would be to use peanuts
or other high-fat grains or seeds, in moderation -- repeat, in
moderation, -- and as well once again, to reduce the protein level
by reducing the amount of legumes such as peas, lentils, etc.
in the diet. (One enterprising and successful fancier I know uses
peanuts only early in the week, but makes good use of the cereal
grains from mid-week to late in the week before shipping. This
procedure likely avoids the pitfall of thirst later in the week,
as pointed out so aptly by Dr. Pawloski.)
At the same time, we should be certain that the amount of carbohydrate
in the diet is at a high level, ie, by the use of a high proportion
of cereal grains, especially grains like corn, wheat, oats and
rice, for example. Glucose or table sugar could be added to the
drinking water to supply extra carbohydrate if necessary. (Note:
Don't put glucose or other sugars in the water day after day.
Use these sugars for only a day at a time, to prevent the growth
of yeasts and molds in the crops of your birds, since these yeasts,
etc. use the sugar as nutrients for their own growth, and can
invade the wall of the crop at this time.) These measures would
take advantage of the fact that when the level of carbohydrate
in the ration is at a reasonably high level, increased dietary
fat does not seem to interfere with fat production by the liver
of birds.
Remember to add grains to a ration by weight, not by volume.
For example, wheat, peas and beans tend to weigh about the same,
ie, if you use say, a coffee can to measure out grain, one can
of wheat will weigh almost the same as one coffee can of peas
or beans. On the other hand, the same coffee can full of barley
or corn will weigh, on the average, about one fifth less than
the same amount of wheat, peas or beans -- so the result is that
you have to add another one fifth of a can of barley or corn to
the mix to be sure that all of the grains mentioned in this example
weigh the same.
One other intriguing but practical method to improve fat production
in racing pigeons could be the use of the sugar fructose. Fructose
is available here as a powder and can be found in health food
stores as well as grocery stores. Compared with table sugar, fructose
may be expensive. Speaking of table sugar, it too is a source
of fructose, since it is composed of one unit of glucose and one
unit of fructose linked together -- two key sugars right in your
own home. Another good source of fructose is honey which contains
about 40% fructose. Why use fructose, when glucose seems to be
the major sugar in the body of birds, the liver of which has a
significant ability to convert glucose to fatty acids in a very
short period of time (Goodridge and Ball, 1967)? First, some background.
Most grains, especially the cereal grains, contain a high per
centage of starch, a complex chemical structure composed of many
individual units of the sugar, glucose.
When the starch in grains is digested by pigeons, it is fractionated
by digestive juices in the intestines into glucose, which is then
absorbed through the intestinal wall into the bloodstream and
transported to the liver. It is known that in birds, the absorption
of glucose from the intestine into the bloodstream far outstrips
the absorption of fructose. However, if fructose is present, it
too will be absorbed from the intestine of birds and transported
to the liver where it is metabolized rapidly. It is significant
that the liver of birds is able to metabolize fructose very rapidly
and efficiently, even if there are also high levels of glucose
present as well. The rapid and efficient metabolism of fructose
by birds is not hindered by simultaneously high levels of glucose
as it seems to be in mammals. Another key fact about fructose
is that in birds, fat production from the metabolism of fructose
exceeds that of all other carbohydrates collectively! Another
highly significant point for us as pigeon flyers is that in birds,
the metabolism of fructose and its conversion to fat receive very
high metabolic priority -- a key fact!
This information offers another practical clue to the process
of fueling pigeons for racing--ie, use fructose to build necessary
fat reserves, especially for the tougher distance events! It seems
to me that the use of fructose could be a major factor in rapidly
rebuilding fat reserves in a pigeon as it races, say in a widowhood
situation, for several weeks in a row. Maybe the problem of "picky
appetite" and the concurrent need to rebuild fat eserves
in widowers might be solved very nicely through the use of fructose,
honey or table sugar in drinking water.
A racing widow/widower may have a capricious appetite at times,
but the more dependable need for a drink of water, to which fructose
can be added for a day to a day and a half, for example, might
provide a partial answer for those birds with the touchy appetites.
Fructose could also be valuable in rapidly rebuilding fat reserves
in exhausted birds when they return from a gruelling race, looking
like shadows of the birds entered originally in the race. It seems
to me that, in looking at these facts, it becomes evident that
feeding high levels of carbohydrates in general, and that feeding
simple sugars such as glucose and fructose specifically, could
be highly valuable in rapidly building fat reserves in racing
birds, virtually when we want them!!
Maybe we don't even need to use so many peanuts or other fat-
containing seeds. Certainly, peanuts and other high-fat grains
can be a mixed blessing, and unless you are completely sure that
you are using high-quality peanuts in the first place, maybe you
should reconsider using them. Those used for human use are probably
the best, but I have seen some peanuts used by pigeon fanciers
and I have shuddered at the thought of any bird being forced to
eat them! Rancidity because of the very high fat content is a
very real danger, especially in the hot summer months if peanuts
are not stored under very cool conditions. Also, certain types
of molds, such as those seen
on moldy bread, for example, can invade peanuts and produce some
nasty
poisons that can induce cancers of the liver in some species.
Obviously, the use of peanuts requires considerable care, and
only those of the very best quality are good enough.
As you can see from reading the foregoing material, there is
a great deal for all of us as fanciers to learn about the nutritional
needs of pigeons! I am fascinated by the number of facts about
the physiological and nutritional characteristics of birds in
general -- all buried in the scientific literature -- and this
article is only a small attempt to expose these facts to the light
of day and to the curiosity of the thinking fancier.
Obviously, this article only scratches the surface of the vast
amount of information and knowledge yet to be discovered and shared
about the feeding of pigeons for racing. As I am not a nutritionist,
I certainly don't claim to have many, or even anyof the answers,
and I would welcome any further input to this fascinating, important
subject. We need facts and we need to share these facts, rather
than burying them as "secrets" to be used only for our
own gain. It would be ideal if a group of thinking fanciers would
get their heads together to run well-constructed trials, complete
with control groups, say over a 3-5 year period, to explore in
a scientific way, the pros and cons of different diets used for
racing. For example, one randomly assembled group of racers would
receive a certain per centage of peanuts in the ration each week,
whereas another randomly assembled group, would be anaged, exercised,
trained and raced in exactly the same way, but not fed peanuts
at all. Overall race results of the two groups could be tabulated
and compared statistically, to determine whether one group raced
better than the
other.
We need solidly performed studies, not the "I-tried-it-for-
a-week-and- it-didn't-work" variety of nonsense that doesn't
prove anything. If enough birds are available in one loft, several
comparative trials using different grains/sugars could be run
at the same time. Naturally, this information needs to be assembled,
evaluated statistically, and just as importantly, published for
the information of all fanciers -- not hidden in the files of
a few fanciers! The sport is hungry for scientific facts that
will help it to develop and grow, and nutrition is certainly a
key area for a lot of work and shared ideas!
Some other related points to consider:
1) The multi-vitamin mix that you buy should
contain vitamin D3 because it is the most highly active form of
the vitamin for birds and animals. Read the label of the product
that you intend to buy to be sure that it contains a wide range
of vitamins, and that the vitamin D is in the form of vitamin
D3. Vitamin products prepared for human use are fine, but are
usually more expensive than those available for poultry.
2) We are told that breeding pigeons can do
well on a diet containing
13-15% protein. One group of investigators found that when pigeons
were offered cereals and peas free choice, the mixture chosen
by the
birds corresponded to a protein intake of 12.5-13%. However, these
investigators also found that a ration containing 18% protein,
obtained by adding soybeans or fish meal to the diet -- which
add high-quality protein -- resulted in optimum hatchability,
growth and development of youngsters.
They also found that levels of protein higher than 18% did not
result in further improvement in growth and weight gains of youngsters.
These
findings indicated that a ration containing upwards of 18% protein,
but not higher, should be ideal for breeding and rearing. Griminger
(1983) also reported that a diet containing 16.5% protein and
supplemented with fish meal and distillers solubles resulted in
similar weaning weights of squabs as those on a commercial diet,
whereas a diet containing 14.7% protein without these supplements
was inferior. Protein is the most costly component of the diet,
and it is wasteful and expensive to feed amounts of protein greater
than those needed for optimum growth of youngsters.
3) To be certain that the systems of both cocks
and hens are nutritionally prepared for the breeding season, a
change from the bland winter diet to a ration higher in protein
needs to take place well in advance of the breeding season. Sheep
breeders use a similar approach and apply the term "flushing"
to indicate feeding a higher level of quality feed prior to the
breeding season. According to one (university) poultry nutritionist
contacted, this dietary change in pigeons should be made about
four weeks prior to pairing the birds.